t4l3nt Governance Overview

t4l3nt Governance Overview

t4l3nt is a self-amending blockchain software based on Tezos which uses an on-chain process to propose, select, test, and activate protocol upgrades without the need to hard fork. In practice, this enables t4l3nt to improve itself over time via a structured, yet decentralized process while preserving a high level of consensus.

t4l3nt also allows stakeholders to upgrade the amendment process itself. As a result, details of the mechanism described below represent the current mechanism and are subject to change. This page will evolve as the network evolves.

Voters / Producers

Producing is how blocks are produced and validated on a t4l3nt blockchain using Liquid Proof-of-Stake. Producers (also known as "delegates") obtain the right to create (i.e. bake) a block when a Reel of tokens (1 Reel = 1,000 ф) they own (or that is delegated to them) is randomly selected to produce or validate a block.

As the maintainers of a t4l3nt network, Producers are also the voters in a t4l3nt formal upgrade process, with their votes proportional to the size of their stake (including delegations).

Votes / Reels

To speed up computations for deciding which delegates are selected to bake, the t4l3nt ledger tracks tokens for staking and governance purposes as "Reels". Reels are aggregated at the delegate level, which means a Producer’s Producing power is proportional to the amount of tokens delegated to them, rounded down to the nearest Reel. A Reel is currently set to 1,000 ф.

Delegators

If someone does not have 1,000 ф or does not want to set up computing infrastructure to bake blocks, they may delegate their tokens to a Producer. The Producer does not own or control the delegated tokens in any way. In particular, it cannot spend them. However, if and when one of these tokens is randomly selected to bake a block, that right will belong to the Producer. In practice, Producers usually share the additional revenue generated from the delegated tokens with the coin holder.

The Five Stages of t4l3nt Governance

The self-amendment process is split into 5 periods: Proposal Period, Exploration Vote Period, Cooldown Period, Promotion Vote Period, and Adoption Period. Each of these five periods lasts five Producing cycles (i.e. 20,480 blocks or roughly 14 days, 5 hours), comprising roughly 2 months and 10 days.

As summarized in the flowchart diagram below, any failure to proceed to the subsequent period reverts the network back to a Proposal Period. In other words, failure to proceed restarts the entire amendment process.

Proposal Period

The t4l3nt amendment process begins with the Proposal Period, during which Producers can submit proposals on-chain using the proposals operation, which involves specifying one or multiple protocol hashes, each one representing a tarball of concatenated .ml/.mli source files.

Producers may submit up to 20 proposals in each Proposal Period. When submitting a proposal, the Producer is also submitting a vote for that proposal, equivalent to the number of Reels in its staking balance at the start of the period.

For those wanting to follow along, t4l3nt Agora and other t4l3nt block explorers such as dcpkt allow you to watch incoming proposals.

Other Producers can then vote on proposals by submitting proposals operations of their own. The Proposal Period vote is done via approval voting, meaning each Producer may vote once on up to 20 proposals. Think of it as a form of “upvoting.”

At the end of the Proposal Period, the network counts the proposal votes. For any proposal to be considered valid, it must have enough upvotes to meet a 5% quorum. If the most upvoted proposal has at least 5% of the number of possible votes supporting it, the proposal proceeds to the Exploration Period. If the 5% quorum is not met, no proposals have been submitted, or there is a tie between proposals, the amendment process resets to a new Proposal Period.

Exploration Period

In the Exploration Period, Producers may vote on the top-ranked proposal from the previous Proposal Period using the ballot operation. Producers get to vote either "Yay", "Nay", or "Pass" on a specific proposal. "Pass" just means to abstain from voting for or against a proposal. As in the Proposal Period, a Producer's vote is based on the number of Reels in its staking balance at the start of the period.

At the end of the Exploration Period, the network counts the votes. If voting participation meets the quorum, and an 80% supermajority of non-abstaining Producers approves, the proposal proceeds to the Testing Period.

If the voting participation fails to achieve the quorum or the 80% supermajority is not met, the amendment process restarts to the beginning of the Proposal Period.

Regardless of the outcome of the vote, the quorum is updated based on past participation rates.

Testing Period

If the proposal is approved in the Exploration Period, the Testing Period begins with a testnet fork that runs in parallel to the main network for 48 hours.

This Testing Period is used to determine whether a proposal is a worthy amendment to the protocol. The testnet fork ensures the upgrade does not corrupt the blockchain network; should the upgrade be adopted, the network would continue making valid state transitions.

Promotion Period

At the end of the Testing Period, the Promotion Period begins. In this period, the network decides whether to adopt the amendment based on off-chain discussions and its behavior during the Testing Period. As in the Exploration Period, Producers submit their votes using the ballot operation, with their votes weighted proportionally to the number of Reels in their staking balance.

At the end of the Promotion Period, the network counts the number of votes. If the participation rate reaches the quorum and an 80% supermajority of non-abstaining Producers votes “Yay,” then the proposal is activated as the new mainnet.

Regardless of the outcome of the vote, the process reverts back to the Proposal Period and the quorum is updated based on past participation rates.

Adoption Period

The Adoption Period provides a "cool-down" allowing developers and Producers some additional time to adapt their code and infrastructure to the upgrade based on the results of the Promotion Vote Period. Adoption period: at the end of the period the proposal is activated as the new protocol and we go back to a proposal period.

Following the adoption period the protocol is activated. After this step the blocks added to the chain are interpreted in the newly activated protocol. As a result gas costs (and other such details of operation inclusion) may differ.

The Supermajority and Quorum Requirements

Proposal Period

A proposal submitted during a Proposal Period needs to reach a quorum (minimum participation rate) in order to advance to the Exploration Period.

Quorum requirement: The number of votes for the most upvoted proposal divided by the number of possible votes must be greater than or equal to 5%.

Exploration & Promotion Periods

A vote during a voting period (Exploration & Promotion) needs to reach both a supermajority and a quorum (minimum participation rate) in order to succeed.

Supermajority requirement: The number of "Yay" votes divided by the number of "Yay" and "Nay" votes must be greater than or equal to 80%.

Quorum requirement: The number of "Yay", "Nay", and "Pass" votes divided by the number of possible votes must be greater than or equal to the current quorum.

Unlike the supermajority requirement which is fixed at 80%, the quorum requirement is updated at the end of each voting period using the following formula, where Q is the quorum in the voting period and q is the participation rate in the voting period:

In other words, the quorum tries to match the exponential moving average of the past participation rate.

Flowchart of the t4l3nt Amendment Process

t4l3nt Client Commands

Voting During a Proposal Period

$ tlnt-client submit proposals for <delegate> <proposal1> <proposal2> ...

Voting During an Exploration or Promotion Period

$ tlnt-client submit ballot for <delegate> <proposal> <yay|nay|pass>

Checking the Status of a Voting Period

$ tlnt-client show voting period

Additional Resources - Relating to Tezos

• The Voting Process from Nomadic Labs

• Amending Tezos from Jacob Arluck